You can know the songs, know the church routine, and still have a question you're nervous to ask.
Maybe you think everybody else already knows the answer. Maybe you're worried it'll sound like you don't believe. Or maybe you've asked before and the answer didn't really deal with what you meant.
That's a big part of why I care about our Answer This series at Open Door Youth. Bella and I worked through questions about relationships, belief, salvation, worship, and things God allows that are hard to understand. There's a lot in that list. And behind every question is a person trying to figure something out.
As a youth pastor, I don't want to miss the person because I'm busy putting together a good answer.
One question was about knowing whether someone is “the one” God sent you. It's easy for that conversation to become all about feelings and signs. You like them, they like you, the timing seems right. Surely that means something, right?
It might. But chemistry isn't a character reference.
The Bible doesn't describe dating as a guessing game where there's one hidden person and one chance to get it right. In 1 Corinthians 7:39, Paul is talking specifically about remarriage, and he describes meaningful choice within faithfulness to the Lord. That gives us something more grounded to work with than trying to decode every feeling.
Does this person love Jesus? Are they honest? How do they treat people they don't need anything from? Can they own it when they're wrong? The sacrificial love described in Ephesians 5 takes more than a strong connection. And for the record, somebody saying “God told me we should date” does not take away your right to say no.
From relationships, the questions took us into why faith can be so controversial. That makes sense when you think about it. We're talking about who God is, why we're here, and how we live. Jesus makes claims people will disagree with. Those conversations can get personal quickly.
But believing something strongly doesn't give me permission to be a jerk about it. First Peter 3:15–16 calls us to explain our hope with gentleness and respect. If I win an argument and treat the person like they don't matter, I've missed something important about the Jesus I'm trying to tell them about.
That also matters when we're talking about people who twist the Bible. Somebody can be confident, popular, and really good at making a point without being right. Galatians 1:6–9 warns about a distorted gospel. First John 4:1–3 tells us to test what we're hearing, especially what it says about Jesus.
That includes what you hear from me. Open your Bible. Read the passage around the verse. Ask questions. I want students to grow in their understanding, not feel like they have to agree because a pastor said it.
Then there were the questions that don't fit into a quick answer. Why doesn't God reveal Himself more clearly to someone who wants to believe? And what about the person who wants faith but still can't seem to get there?
I think we need to slow down here. We don't know someone's whole story. We shouldn't hear that they're struggling and immediately decide they haven't tried, or that they're secretly looking for an excuse.
Scripture tells us God has revealed Himself through creation and most clearly through Jesus. It doesn't explain why every sincere seeker has a different experience, or why one person finds something convincing while another still has questions.
Thomas struggled to believe Jesus had risen, and Jesus met him with evidence and called him to believe (John 20:24–29). In Mark 9:24, a father brought both belief and unbelief to Jesus while asking for help for his son. Those stories don't make doubt the goal. They show us that we can bring the struggle to Jesus.
Salvation comes through Jesus, by grace through faith. It isn't a prize for answering every question correctly (Ephesians 2:8–9). At the same time, sincerely searching isn't a separate way to salvation, and the Bible's warnings about unbelief and judgment are serious. I don't want to soften those truths. I also don't want to act like a short description of someone's doubts tells me everything about their heart. God knows what I don't.
Sometimes being a pastor means saying, “Let's keep working through this,” instead of pretending one conversation has solved it. I can point someone toward Jesus clearly and still admit there are things I can't explain.
Even the question about worship songs brought us back to slowing down and paying attention. A song can sound amazing and give you chills. That doesn't automatically mean everything it says about God is true.
And using “I” or “me” doesn't automatically make a song selfish. Read the Psalms. They're full of personal prayer, gratitude, grief, and trust. What matters is what those words are saying to God and about Him. Jesus connects worship with spirit and truth in John 4:23–24, and Colossians 3:16 connects our singing with the message of Christ.
So read the lyrics. Think about what you're singing. Bring your heart into it, absolutely, but bring your understanding too.
Another question asked why Adam was punished if Satan sinned first. Genesis 3 doesn't describe Adam taking Satan's punishment. Adam was responsible for his own disobedience. Temptation is real, but someone else's wrongdoing doesn't erase our choices.
Romans 5:12–19 then points us from Adam's disobedience toward the grace and righteousness that come through Jesus. That's where this gets hopeful. We can own our sin without believing it has to be the end of our story. We can turn to Jesus for forgiveness.
Looking back at these questions, I keep thinking about the trust it takes to ask them. I don't want someone to work up the courage to be honest and leave feeling small because of how I responded.
Helping people Know God, Find Freedom, Discover Purpose, and Make a Difference includes conversations like these. It includes listening when a question comes out a little messy. It includes opening the Bible together and being willing to keep talking.
So if you're still asking questions, keep bringing them into the light. Read the passages in context. Find someone trustworthy who will take you seriously. You don't have to fake certainty to have a seat in the conversation.
And if you're the person being asked, take a breath before you jump in. You don't have to know everything. Start by caring about the person in front of you, and help them take their next step toward Jesus.
More writing